Urban Decay Naked Metal Mania Palette is the newest iteration in the Naked range, and it was truly hilarious to see almost every single shimmer shade come shattered. A little too much headbanging, eh? That was Ulta’s fault for sure, since they just slipped it into a bubble envelope and sent it out.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Comments that do not adhere to our
comment policy may be
removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to
participate respectfully.
Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an
off-topic question, or need technical support, please
contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above
for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't
answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but
will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when
a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set
expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up
being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
I know that I saw one of my favorite YouTubers swatch it and didn’t think it looked bad, per se, but rather boring and like UD has banged “Naked” to death already!
(Minus one fuchsia and a bright gold, that is)
Christina D.
I was relieved that UD Naked Metal Mania made it to me intact since Ulta’s packaging isn’t always reliable. As far as the palette itself, I wasn’t sure what to expect since UD releases have been more of a miss than a hit. But I have used it and I’m glad to say that I love it! It’s pigmented, easy to blend, and zero fallout. In my experience, the colors were even richer than your swatches, but I do use primer. Glad to be happy with a UD purchase again.
Initial response is that there isn’t anything Earth shattering here. I have so many beautiful shimmer/duochrome shades that these all look a bit mundane. They look like they swatch okay.
There is nothing really here in this palette for me to love or even like – seeing as I still have the original three nakeds and they are still stunning.
That’s pretty bad of Ulta to be so shoddy with their wrapping.
Too warm for me and I’m not a fan of the UD formula. Ulta has been really bad with packaging lately. The majority of my orders are also shipped in that bubble bag, including some larger orders that are shoved inside and arrive with crushed packaging, some broken items and the bag splitting on the side.
Ulta has been so bad with palettes lately I don’t want to buy from them unless it’s pickup at a store. Any soft formula gets smashed. They even put my Tom Ford perfume order in one of those bubble mailers and shipped it. Box was crushed, but the perfume was intact. Geez.
Cara
The same thing happened to me! I recently repurchased 3 travel size bottles of Mugler’s Alien and a moisturizer that comes in an overly large jar and Ulta crammed all 4 items into a bubble bag. It arrived with every box crushed and the caps of 2 bottles were off. The travel size had been out of stock everywhere for a year and I had been without it for a few months so I bought multiple thinking they would sell out again immediately and I was so angry when they arrived like they did bc they were only available online at the time and if they broke, I’d end up dealing with the same issue. I don’t understand why the warehouse staff thinks it’s acceptable to ship glass items like that
While UD has long lost most interest of mine, I’m always impressed at how things are shipped nowadays. Recently had a coffee mug come in bubble wrap inside polymailer & some straw cowboy hats rolled up like burritos & smashed flat that was also shipped in a polymailer. Impressive job on the shipping Ulta! Broken shadows to that extent is beyond impressive. And they will offer to replace, yet ship again the same way!
What is up with the name 🤔 Indie Sleaze?? I was super excited for a black in this amazing formula but from the looks of the lip swatch it’s a no go 😫 the others look promising as fitting in with the prior line amazing liq lipsticks. Plan on getting crushing for sure. I’m not liking the palette rather 😴😴😴
I really like the look of Crushing. I suspect I have duped for it though.
As for the palette, can I have a quad that includes Power Cord, Spike Stud, Scene and Road Crew. I really like those four shades, I probably have dupes. The first three are too warm, the first four shimmers look like shades I have about a dozen of and Heavy is lookin rather sad.
I do look forward to reviews.
Indie Sleaze could have been really great, I like the colour applied, but not the application, if that makes sense.
I swatched a few of the shimmers in person at Ulta, and I was pleasantly surprised. They reminded me more of the old UD formula than the dry, hard-pan Naked Ultraviolet palette that was such a disaster. But it’s a no for me on this color story. It’s . . . odd, yet boring? But keep going, UD! You can do it!
Ulta has been shipping palettes out lately in flimsy, paper envelopes. I can’t imagine replacing all these shattered palettes is cheaper than shipping in a more secure way.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get
behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback,
product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please
contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Ironically, the shade Heavy looks so weak! 😛
I know that I saw one of my favorite YouTubers swatch it and didn’t think it looked bad, per se, but rather boring and like UD has banged “Naked” to death already!
(Minus one fuchsia and a bright gold, that is)
I was relieved that UD Naked Metal Mania made it to me intact since Ulta’s packaging isn’t always reliable. As far as the palette itself, I wasn’t sure what to expect since UD releases have been more of a miss than a hit. But I have used it and I’m glad to say that I love it! It’s pigmented, easy to blend, and zero fallout. In my experience, the colors were even richer than your swatches, but I do use primer. Glad to be happy with a UD purchase again.
This is excellent news, Christina. I hope that perhaps it signals a turnaround for the brand.
Initial response is that there isn’t anything Earth shattering here. I have so many beautiful shimmer/duochrome shades that these all look a bit mundane. They look like they swatch okay.
There is nothing really here in this palette for me to love or even like – seeing as I still have the original three nakeds and they are still stunning.
That’s pretty bad of Ulta to be so shoddy with their wrapping.
The palette is kinda upstaged by the Lip Bonds! The black looks underwhelming, though 🙁
Too warm for me and I’m not a fan of the UD formula. Ulta has been really bad with packaging lately. The majority of my orders are also shipped in that bubble bag, including some larger orders that are shoved inside and arrive with crushed packaging, some broken items and the bag splitting on the side.
Ulta has been so bad with palettes lately I don’t want to buy from them unless it’s pickup at a store. Any soft formula gets smashed. They even put my Tom Ford perfume order in one of those bubble mailers and shipped it. Box was crushed, but the perfume was intact. Geez.
The same thing happened to me! I recently repurchased 3 travel size bottles of Mugler’s Alien and a moisturizer that comes in an overly large jar and Ulta crammed all 4 items into a bubble bag. It arrived with every box crushed and the caps of 2 bottles were off. The travel size had been out of stock everywhere for a year and I had been without it for a few months so I bought multiple thinking they would sell out again immediately and I was so angry when they arrived like they did bc they were only available online at the time and if they broke, I’d end up dealing with the same issue. I don’t understand why the warehouse staff thinks it’s acceptable to ship glass items like that
While UD has long lost most interest of mine, I’m always impressed at how things are shipped nowadays. Recently had a coffee mug come in bubble wrap inside polymailer & some straw cowboy hats rolled up like burritos & smashed flat that was also shipped in a polymailer. Impressive job on the shipping Ulta! Broken shadows to that extent is beyond impressive. And they will offer to replace, yet ship again the same way!
What is up with the name 🤔 Indie Sleaze?? I was super excited for a black in this amazing formula but from the looks of the lip swatch it’s a no go 😫 the others look promising as fitting in with the prior line amazing liq lipsticks. Plan on getting crushing for sure. I’m not liking the palette rather 😴😴😴
I really like the look of Crushing. I suspect I have duped for it though.
As for the palette, can I have a quad that includes Power Cord, Spike Stud, Scene and Road Crew. I really like those four shades, I probably have dupes. The first three are too warm, the first four shimmers look like shades I have about a dozen of and Heavy is lookin rather sad.
I do look forward to reviews.
Indie Sleaze could have been really great, I like the colour applied, but not the application, if that makes sense.
I swatched a few of the shimmers in person at Ulta, and I was pleasantly surprised. They reminded me more of the old UD formula than the dry, hard-pan Naked Ultraviolet palette that was such a disaster. But it’s a no for me on this color story. It’s . . . odd, yet boring? But keep going, UD! You can do it!
Can’t wait to see the dups for Spike Stud.
Ulta has been shipping palettes out lately in flimsy, paper envelopes. I can’t imagine replacing all these shattered palettes is cheaper than shipping in a more secure way.